Hamilton vs. Kant: pitting adaptations for altruism against adaptations for moral judgment
نویسندگان
چکیده
Prominent evolutionary theories of morality maintain that the adaptations that underlie moral judgment and behavior function, at least in part, to deliver benefits (or prevent harm) to others. These explanations are based on the theories of kin selection and reciprocal altruism, and they predict that moral systems are designed to maximize Hamiltonian inclusive fitness. In sharp contrast, however, moral judgment often appears Kantian and rule-based. To reconcile this apparent discrepancy, some theorists have claimed that Kantian moral rules result from mechanisms that implement simple heuristics for maximizing welfare. To test this idea, we conducted a set of studies in which subjects (N=1290) decided whether they would kill one person to save five others, varying the relationship of the subject with the others involved (strangers, friends, brothers). Are participants more likely to observe the Kantian rule against killing in decisions about brothers and friends, rather than strangers? We found the reverse. Subjects reported greater willingness to kill a brother or friend than a stranger (in order to save five others of the same type). These results suggest that the rule-based structure of moral cognition is not explained by kin selection, reciprocity, or other altruism theories. © 2012 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
منابع مشابه
The structural adaptations of Convolvulus persicus, an endangered plant in the northern coasts of Iran
The purpose of this research was to identify the structural adaptations in three populations of Convolvulus persicus L. on coastal areas in Mazandaran Province, whose populations of which are severely reducing due to the intense environmental stresses of the coastal zone. In general, annular collenchyma, isobilateral mesophyll, amphiphloic siphonostele, abundant presence of laticiferous tubes, ...
متن کاملInvestigating the factors affecting whistle-blowing by employees in the hospital
Background: The occurrence of all kinds of errors and mistakes imposes many costs on the hospital and society. Whistleblowing and error reporting plays an essential role in preventing and reducing errors, but the rate of error reporting in hospitals is low. This research was conducted in order to investigate the effect of selected individual factors on whistleblowing of hospital employees. M...
متن کاملA Critical Review of Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Judgment and a Guideline on its Developmental Stages
A Critical Review of Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Judgment and a Guideline on its Developmental Stages A.R. Assaareh, Ph.D. * A. Mahdizaadeh Tehraani** A.R. Amini Zarrin*** S. Azimi**** Developmental theories describe and explain stages in which different aspects of human psyche develop. Among such theories is Kohlberg’s theory of moral judgment wherein a complex ...
متن کامل09 Chapter 1724
THE ‘PROBLEM OF ALTRUISM’ has remained a thorn in the side of evolutionary biology since Darwin. In On the origin of species (1860), Darwin clearly recognized that the widespread existence of altruistic behavioural adaptations was a potential problem for his theory of natural selection. The general problem is that, if nature is ‘red in tooth and claw’ and natural selection produces adaptations ...
متن کامل